Beef Stock Cream Chardonnay Whole Grain Mustard Lemon Juice Salt Pepper
Sort by: Most Helpful
Most Helpful Most Positive Least Positive Newest
07/09/2002
I first found this recipe on this site in 2002, and made the dish for my then boyfriend, and now husband. It's still a regular on my home menu. I made some initial changes, which perfected the recipe for us and which I've kept all these years: 1) I omit the lemon juice altogether 2) I add about 1/4 cup chopped parsley which adds beautiful color, scent and a slight lemony flavor that makes up for the missing lemon juice and 3) I always saute shrimp or chicken in the pan with garlic and olive oil FIRST, then spoon it onto a dish and set aside, before using the same pan to make the sauce. This will add a lot of flavor to the sauce. Then after the sauce is made, add back the shrimp/chicken along with cooked pasta, mix and then dish up and serve. GREAT!
12/28/2001
To truckerdoo--the sauce curdled because you used milk and not heavy cream as the recipe indicates. There is not enough fat in milk to keep the sauce from breaking. If you're trying to make the recipe lower in fat you'd need to experiment with a combination of heavy cream and milk to keep the sauce from breaking.
01/23/2002
From reading the reviews that others had posted, one would gather that these were submitted my inexperienced members...milk? (8^D) I tried your recipe, and my friends and I were extremely pleased with the results. Not too difficult; not too time consuming. The cream came out very rich and flavorful, and I believe that by estimating the amounts of wine, garlic and lemon juice, I was able to achieve a wonderful balance. (I try to use recipes as a foundation for creation rather than direct instruction - this allows me to experience how different amounts of ingredients will effect the end result and to adjust for different tastes geographically...) Thank you for providing a wonderful foundation for a memorable dinner with my closest friends.
06/13/2004
Followed this recipe exactly and the flavor was good but the consistency wasn't the best. Be sure to constantly watch the sauce because the wine reduces super fast - I moved away from the pan and when I returned the shallots were almost ready to burn! But the flavor was excellent, and I'll probably try this recipe again with a constant eye on the pan.
12/13/2006
An absolutely great basis really for your own recipes. For example try adding bacon when frying the garlic. My only complaint was that it was too runny. So I'll use slightly less wine next time. But it's definitely a keeper.
09/19/2007
I thought the sauce was a little sour, but that's maybe because of the white wine, that I used. Next time I will be more careful when adding the lemon juice. I would suggest adding smoked salmon, fresh basil or bacon to the sauce.
10/02/2001
Quite tasty. Although next time I will cut the lemon in half. I found it a little overpowering for my taste. I also added a tbs of flour to the sauce, as I found that it didn't thicken at all. Other then that it was quite good. Will make again :)
01/19/2011
sooo yummy! I have made this over and over and it always turns out yummy. I didnt have any shallots last time, so I made it with red onions... i think it was even better.
12/15/2002
Excellent flavored sauce. I didn't have a lemon, so I used 2t of bottled lemon juice. This sauce really tasted good over scallops and chicken breast. Thanks for sharing.
10/20/2006
Good recipe. Did use less lemon (just do it to your own personal preference) and added more fresh minced garlic per the other reviews. I also didn't bother with having the heavy whipping cream at room temperature.
11/04/2005
This really is good... but you have to do some work first! Less lemon is RIGHT! I started with a tablespoon and worked up, finally ending at about 2 1/2 T. I think it would have been too much otherwise. Also, I never cook with real onion - I used dried minced onion and it worked great. The description on this said it's thick and creamy, which wasn't the case with mine, but it worked out fine. We made this fantastic by using it to top lightly breaded chicken, then served it alongside linguine alfredo. The lemon and alfredo blend together beautifully... there's a chain restaurant I used to go to in NC called Ragazzi's, and they have a dish called Chicken Limonata, and this is a lot like it. SUPERB!
02/16/2010
MUCH too much lemon juice, and I'm a lemon-lover. The sauce was just sour from all the lemon juice. I was expecting a nice creamy wine-tasting sauce, but what I got was a runny, sour-tasting sauce. I do not recommend making this as written.
03/30/2002
I followed the recipe with the exception of two things: after adding the wine to the shallots and garlic and boiling to reduce it, I strained the liquid, then added the cream; also, I thought that the shallots, garlic and wine added enough piquancy to the sauce, so I left out the lemon juice. I plan to serve this with roast lamb at Easter dinner. This is a delicious sauce and I'm filing the recipe among my other favorites. Many thanks to Claire for her recipe and inspiration.
05/10/2009
Followed recipe exactly, minus the shallots and garlic. Never thickened and way too strong on the lemon.
03/24/2008
My 2nd time making it I decided to use a larger pan so there was more surface for evaporation. This unfortunately meant the wine almost completely evaporated, but mixing it in w/the cream did make for an incredible flavour. I also doubled the amount of cream b/c of the lack of wine left in the pan. Fabulous.
08/18/2010
I had to make emergency alterations to this recipe, which I made tonight. My heavy cream went BAD so I used ladle full of spaghetti water, whole milk + melted butter for the final step and then stirred in 2 tsps white flour to thicken it up. I also added a can of drained mushrooms and a bunch of finely shopped fresh italian parsley. Topped with parmesan and it was GREAT. Horribly fattening no doubt but it was a big hit. I'd make this again no question. OH, also I used cracked black pepper instead of white to add a bit of color as well.
06/09/2012
Great sauce, I did add a tbl spoon of flour to thicken. Other than that it was very good. But next time I'm doubling the recipe, I like to have sauce to dip in.
02/27/2012
This is a beautiful cream sauce. We really loved it.
10/19/2001
This was the pitts! The wine made it awfully sour, and when I added the milk, it curdled terribly. Perhaps I did something wrong, but I tried three times (wasted a whole bunch of ingredients) and in the end just had to go with an entirely different recipe. Plus, this yielded SO much sauce that it was more like alfredo soup than sauce.
02/03/2004
This is a delicious sauce -- phenomenal actually! I did not give it 4 stars, however, because it lacks a precise measurement for teh lemon juice -- start with 1 tablespoon and then increase to taste. I failed to do this this first time I made the sauce and added sugar to taste to compensate for the tartness.
11/03/2010
I would have given it 2 stars but I must have done something wrong, so am giving 3. It sounded like it would be very good, but mine ended up just tasting like heavy cream.
10/15/2009
Served this with wild mushroom flavored linguine. I did not use the lemon. This turned out delicious, but it was more runny than creamy. Also, I will cut back on the shallots next time, because they dominated the make up of this sauce. I will probably try this again. Good with French bread.
08/02/2008
I didn't like this sauce at all. It needs flavor and less wine.
01/28/2009
This is one of my favorites! I added parm cheese to make it more of an alfredo sauce and it is sooo good!
09/10/2013
I would never spend the time making this again. Didn't find the instructions particularly well done.
08/20/2010
Unless you're cooking for two, I recommend doubling this recipe. And as others, I also only used half the amount of lemon.
03/24/2009
I cut this recipe in half, and it was still fantastic. Be sure not to cook on too high of a heat or all your liquid will evaporate.
07/01/2015
Made this today for big dinner party tomorrow night going to let sit all night for the flavors to blend together and let the meatballs soak in the flavors all night. I did the recipe for 10 servings the taste is great I did use less lemon. Cant wait for the flavors to blend together over night. Did add a little flour to thicken.
08/25/2007
I just made this as a pizza sauce over a whole wheat crust with mozzarella, proscuitto, roasted eggplant, and tomato. It was fantastic! Definitely use half the lemon juice (maybe quarter depending on your taste). Use a good white wine--one you would actually want to drink. And don't add the cream until the wine is almost entirely evaporated. Thanks for this recipe!
08/09/2009
Loved this recipe, really easy to figure out, cooked it for about 5 friends after moving them into a new apartment. Didnt use as much garlic, but I did add fresh cut basil, oregano, and cilantro, added good color to the sauce and really boosted the flavor. I served it with penne, and sauteed red and orange peppers, red and green onions, and roma tomatoes, a really great way to do this for my vegetarian friends!
07/14/2015
This was so good! My husband even loved it! made a couple small changes (dont you hate it when people say its good and then say they changed it??) I didnt use shallots, doubled the garlic (cause you can never have too much), and after I added the cream; I added basil, salt and a cornstarch mix to thicken (1T cornstarch, 2T water). Like others mentioned, I also cut the lemon in 1/2. I added shrimp that I had sauteed in butter and garlic and served over fettuccine noodles. This is a keeper......
03/29/2018
If you want to taste anything else than lemon, put a teaspoon at best. Juice of one lemon is way too much. It is all you will taste.
05/26/2011
this was a hit with me and my hubby..the kids not so much but what do they know. the only thing i'd change was the amount im gonna double it nxt time. I added chicken breast to. yummy
01/17/2010
too lemony, runny, none of my family would eat it
07/26/2020
Wasn't that good
01/15/2004
I found that the shallots over powered the garlic, and the lemon left the sauce bitter and the sauce was thinner than I had anticipated. I think I could be good with a lot less lemon, a bit less wine and a little thickening. I think it just lacks a little balance.
03/09/2008
I've used this recipe a number of times as a foundation; I then add in mushrooms, sundried tomatoes and chunks of sauted chicken and serve over pasta. Delicious...Thanks for a great sauce.
07/08/2015
Came out very tasty but next I will only use half a lemon
05/19/2014
I loved this recipe! I did add a little grated cheese to it & it turned out wonderful. I saw someone suggest adding a little bacon; i"ll have to try that too :)Overall, this will become a weekly hit in our house!
07/21/2020
This sauce is delicious! I made it for a larger crowd so I altered the amounts of the ingredients, following mostly what the recipe said. For 5 ppl I had 4 large shallots, 8 large cloves or garlic, juice of 1 large lemon, 1 ¼ cup heavy cream and a full bottle of wine. I topped it with some fresh grated asiago cheese and some herbs from my garden and voilà ! I also used a corn starch slurry to help thicken the sauce ever so slightly. I'll be using this again, but next time I may put the cheese (like parmesan etc) directly in the sauce when I add in the cream.
11/18/2015
Great sauce, I made this with a pino grigio, I added bell pepper (just because I had it laying around), and I added bacon per another reviewer's suggestion. I don't mind sauces that aren't super thick, because the pasta will soak up the extra liquid in no time. The wine reduced almost down to nothing, and the flavor was big and bold. If you want the sauce thicker, don't add flour! Just pour it over your pasta and let it stand 10 minutes, then stir. Beware that if you add bacon like I did, cut back on the extra salt addition.
02/13/2017
I substituted heavy cream for a milk/butter/flour mixture. It made the sauce VERY thick. I also added sliced mushrooms during the last 5 minutes of the 10 minute boiling. I would definitely make this sauce again, hopefully with cream next time!
03/03/2013
I used this as a base for a lemon garlic cream sauce for chicken. I omitted the cream cheese and Parmesan cheese and added 2 tsp of cornstarch that I had mixed in 4 tsp of cold water. I then grated the rind of I lemon bs the lemon juice, let simmer till thick. Tossed in a handful of chopped chives at the end and served over chicken. The family LOVED it and are asking for it again already!!
03/28/2008
This was a good base but needed a few changes. Only used 2 tablespoons of lemon juice. Any more would have made the sauce too tart. Once the cream was added I reduced it for about 10mins as I like a thick sauce. Served it with some Veal Ravioli.
09/30/2018
This is a great base recipe, some changes though- omit the lemon all together and cook the shrimp separately in a pan with lemon then add the shrimp to the finished product.
03/17/2018
I also thought it was a bit sour and I used a cup of cream (not 3/4)C. I used Sauvignon Blanc. It's also not a thick sauce. It came out better after I added freshly grated parmesan cheese. I made bowtie pasta, grilled chicken, sliced mini yellow/red peppers and spinach.
09/13/2015
I made this tonight and no one liked it.
01/27/2004
I agree with others that say it is a bit sour. I used half the amount of lemon it asked for and next time I will use even less maybe a couple of teaspoons. Other than that it was excellent and so easy to make!
02/19/2010
This was very nice. I didn't have shallots, so used onion and I added fresh chopped tomatoes and slices of leftover brats at the very end. Everyone loved it.
02/03/2003
The taste is superb but it came out a lot thinner than what I had expected.
07/20/2014
We added shrimp and this is so good! The only thing I will add next time is fresh Oregano. Easy to prepare and delicious!! This recipe is a keeper :-) Can't wait for next time!
02/04/2021
Was tired of the same old alfredo sauce. Shopped around and found this. Winner! Made it close to recipe, but added mushrooms. Served it over spinich & cheese ravioli. So good. No leftovers! FYI there are only two of us.
01/13/2020
Oh my gosh you guys I have made so many cream sauces in my life and this one is incredible! I always follow it to a tee and it comes out exactly what I want every time. Tonight I'm mixing it with cavatapi noodles with cherry tomatoes and fresh spinach and baking it with herbed bread crumbs. So good. Last time I breaded a chicken breast and pan fried it, then put some of this sauce over the chicken and wow!!!
12/28/2004
I agree with using less lemon - I hadn't read the reviews beforehand and used 3/4 of a lemon (it's what I had), and it was too lemony. I didn't have shallots, so I used chinese chives and added a premix of 1 Tbsp of cornstarch mixed with 2 Tbsp of water after stirring in the cream to thicken up the sauce (I only had heavy whipping cream on hand). I used it over pasta and it came out nicely (except for the lemoniness, which I'll change next time).
04/11/2012
I tried this sauce and followed directions and the sauce ended up very thin.
06/03/2020
Excellent taste besides being slightly too bittery (wine). Wish it was a little thicker. Next time I will add a little less wine and whisk the sauce to thicken a little more.
01/28/2020
So made as written but then doctored so we could eat it. If I was to do this again: I'd choose a very mild wine or use 1/2 chicken broth. (I added bullion to fix mine as the wine I used was tart/bitter and overwhelmed the sauce). I also ended up using some grated Parmesan cheese and a wee bit of flour to thicken it (although adding al dente pasta and heating through prob was enough). My wine was tart. I cannot imagine adding lemon. A sweeter wine though might have needed it. This really depends on what wine you use.
12/01/2012
Yummy! My hubby was heating the leftovers up for a couple days, cause they were so good. :-)
08/16/2007
The base for a good meal is there but the lemon destroys an otherwise good recipe. Possibly exchange the lemon juice for s small amount of zest or leave it out entirely.
12/19/2017
Awful!! Waaayyy too much lemon and wine! The wife dumped out more than half, added butter, basil, oregano, and more cream....still terrible
01/19/2018
This does not match the original which used no wine at all. The flavor was good but not what I expected. The texture (for me) was also off. I used this recipe with pasta and shrimp. Here is what I did different Par cook the shrimp in garlic butter clarified) and set aside. To make the garlic butter i fine sliced garlic and sweat'd it for about 30 minutes, strained through a strainer in order to reuse the butter. Next i par cooked the shrimp in this butter, set aside. I added a little more butter to what was in the pan and cooked the shallot (2 instead of 3) and garlic similar to the instructions. Using the same pan I combined all of the wine. I used sauvignon blanc for this as it has a little less bite. I did not use any lemon juice as the wine provided more than enough acid. Keeping the heat on high I reduced the wine to almost au sec (dry). If i dragged a wooden spoon on the bottom of the pan there was a trail that did not collapse upon itself until the spoon was halfway across the pan. It is impossible to go by time here. There was maybe a 1/8 inch of wine left in the bottom. I did not follow the above directions and ended up with too much wine and had to add more cream. After adding the cream reduce until the back of a rubber spatula is coated. At this point I added the shrimp (to finish cooking) and the pasta to warm back up. Flavor was good. I did not care for the amount of shallot in my mouth. Next time I would puree and then add back in to make a smoother sauce. Fo
09/25/2007
The flavor, in my opinion, was great. However, when following the recipe it ended up quite water-y. I would probably add something to thicken it. I actually used about 3/4 of the lemon and it worked very well. I also love the small ringlets that you can cut the shallots into.
07/15/2021
No changes... Absolutely love this sauce!!
03/30/2016
Delicious!!! :D We followed this recipe and added some parmesan cheese, nutmeg, and an egg yolk for some more OOMPH, but really lovely recipe!
10/13/2006
EXCELLENT! When I prepared this for my grandmother-in-law who is a VERY Picky eater- she said" this is delicious- restuarant quality" We just love this sauce...
01/03/2005
Too Much Lemon, not thick enough, not enough garlic, and not "creamy". You may also want to chop the shallots. I ended up having to doctor the sauce quite a bit to even get it close to tasting ok. I used it with the basil pasta recipe that is on this site, and the contrast between the green pasta, and the white sauce was nice, but don't waste your time. The white pepper also isn't the best idea. Cracked black pepper worked better. Overall, I was sad that I wasted a half bottle of wine on this sauce when my dinner guests and I could have sipped it with a good sauce.
01/27/2014
I prefer to pretty much stick to the recipe as written for the first time. I did so with this too, though I did put very little lemon in, as we don't like strong lemon in a dish like this. So, though I wondered about the amount of shallots called for, I went with it. They did cook down a lot, but the "sauce" was still more like shallots with a bit of cream over them. I had been looking for a garlic cream sauce, and this was horribly disappointing. That said, I think it might be good with far, far less shallots. And/or if you want a strong onion flavor. Oh, and I would at least chop the shallots, as opposed to just slicing.
06/07/2018
This sauce is really good! Absolutely delicious with lobster ravioli! Playing around with different white wines changes the flavors, but it's never come out bad. It does kinda seem like there's not much of it though, I'd recommend making one and a half or doubling the recipe (maybe except for the shallots) if you're making it for more than 4 people.
06/28/2013
We put less lemon and it was an absolute hit!
11/06/2015
Loved this. Used evaporated milk, scallions instead of shallots, added parmesan cheese once the cream part was added. Used only a slither of limon acido, and at the very end, added the shrimp I had cooked separately with a bit of its buttery liquid to the sauce and fresh chopped tomatoes and it turned out perfect. Delish!
02/02/2008
This was AMAZING! I had a bottle of white wine that I friend left at my house that I had nothing to do with. This was the first wine sauce I have ever tried to make. My family was very happy with it!
12/18/2008
very good for how i use it.....as a sauce to put my cracked crab into. Consequently, the lemon flavor is very appropriate and needs a less thick consistancy. Must use a dry wine, great to incorperate another herb or fish flavor but more than one is too much.
04/08/2019
I love lemon wine sauce and this one is easy and good. I'm not sure why the recipe says it takes an hour to make, it took nowhere near that. Maybe thirty minutes. I didn't have shallots so I used half of a large white onion. I also didn't have a fresh lemon so I used 2 1/2 tablespoons of lemon juice. It was a strong lemon flavor but I like that. I wonder if reviewers complaining about it being too tart have ever had chicken picatta. This is basically that sauce, it's supposed to be tart. I didn't use any meat, I just coated bow tie pasta with it and topped with capers. I think next time I'll add asparagus or broccoli.
10/08/2010
soo very very good over porkchops and linguine
02/13/2017
I had guest coming over to dinner one night. About 2 1/2 hrs before they were to arrive, I received a call telling me one of the guest could not eat any red sauce. I turned to Allrecipes.com found this recipe. It turned out fantastic. Then everyone wanted a taste it. I was asked for the recipe from a few of my guest.
07/24/2004
This recipe is good but only used 1/4-1/2 of a lemon a whole lemon over powers it and make the sauce taste like one big lemon.
09/17/2005
It didn't taste right... I would suggest trying it without the lemon first to see if it is better that way.
10/08/2012
Added a little parm cheese at the very end, just a couple sprinkles, so delicious!
09/26/2017
I loved it! I added sliced baby portabellas, other than that followed the recipe. Tasted Great, will definently be making again!
02/17/2016
good
Source: https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/26311/white-wine-and-garlic-dream-cream/
0 Response to "Beef Stock Cream Chardonnay Whole Grain Mustard Lemon Juice Salt Pepper"
Post a Comment